Civil Challenge No. 2019-02

[Iae]

I, Iae, on the behalf of myself and of Samogkir, have submitted the following:

Reference Number: 2019-02
Submitted: 27 August 2019
Presiding Judge: Xingal

Plantiff(s): Iae, Member of Congress; Samogkir, Member of Congress

Defendant(s): Dankass Communes, Discord Administrator

Request: Various declaratory relief; injunctive relief requiring the overturning of Samogkir's ban from the DSA Discord
Full Text: Accessible via this link

[Iae]

I, Iae, on behalf of myself and Samogkir, have submitted the following motion:

Motion for Defendant Response Deadline and Conditional Grant of Default Judgement

In the matter of:
Iae, in their capacity as a Member of Congress
Samogkir, in their capacity as a Member of Congress
v.
Dankass Communes, in their capacity as Discord Administrator

Dated: 31 August 2019
Request: Setting of a deadline for answer by the Defendant on 3 September, and grant of default judgement if the Defendant or their counsel does not answer
Full text: Accessible here

[xingal]

After checking all available evidence, I, in my office as the high judge of the DSA, came to the conclusion that the second strike against Samogkir contested in this civil challenge was in accordance to the law and will therefore not be repealed.

Ever since first appearing in the DSA, Samogkir had done nothing but troll and incite people, even after being explicitly asked to stop multiple times, and also expressed explicit anti-DSA sentiments on multiple occasions, going as far as stating that he hates the region. Therefore, he never showed any signs of regretting past actions and just continued his behavior through to his second and third strike. Also, while the second strike might not have been explicitly mentioned in the Discord rules, his behavior in this case, again, is clearly trolling, which falls under inflammatory behavior in the rules. He pinged cabinet over a stupid meme, twice, demanding an immediate answer to an obviously not serious question. This is breaking, if not the letter, then definitely the spirit of the law, a behavior which will not be tolerated just as it won't be tolerated any other place in the world. Furthermore, I will even go as far as follow Dank's recommendation to issue a permaban from the region for Samogkir.

With this, the civil challenge shall be considered closed.